As part of the 2021 revamp of F1, one of the key cost savings being considered is the switch to a carefully selected number of spec parts. The list is quite short and for the large part will go unnoticed by the fans and teams. The tender for the gearbox cartridge has already been published by the FIA and another three tenders have recently been released for the brake system, brake material and wheels
In terms of specification the current calipers are quite tightly constrained, being fixed to six pistons, aluminium lithium material and just two fasteners bolting the caliper to the suspension upright.
At present teams purchase their brake calipers and master cylinders. Brembo is the most widely-used supplier, others include Akebono (McLaren), 920e (Racing Point) and AP Racing. BBW unit supply is shrouded in confidentiality, but being a hydraulic control system they may be of the teams’ own designs, or perhaps produced in partnership with their braking suppliers.
Even with eight teams running the same supplier’s calipers, each individual team will run its own variation to suit their particular hose connections and cooling requirements. So the future supply of a spec caliper will reduce the options for teams, cutting costs at the same time and with little performance loss.
Some revised technical details are apparent in the tender. Firstly the material choice will switch from aluminium lithium to 2618 or an equivalent aluminium alloy, this will be a cost reducing change. However, with this change will be a loss in the stiffness of the component, which is a critical factor in the effectiveness of the caliper.
Fortunately the other change in 2021 is to larger diameter wheels, so despite the caliper wrapping around a bigger 320/330mm disc, there will still be more space to build a larger and thus stiffer caliper by having a strong bridge section, which is the part that connects the left and right side of the caliper.
Driving brake fluid to the calipers is the job of the master cylinder. Currently F1 cars run dual master cylinders, with the pedal compressing two separate master cylinders (one each for the front and rear brakes) via a bias bar. With different master cylinder bore sizes and the geometry of the bias bar the pedal will send a proportionate amount of pressure to both the front and rear brakes.
Until 2014 the front-to-rear bias ratio could be tweaked by the driver using a cockpit adjuster which moved the bias bar on the pedal. Since then the rear braking has been taken care of by the BBW unit.
Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter and
With this system the rear master cylinder creates pressure, though in normal use it is not directed to the caliper, but to the BBW unit as an input for braking demand. The BBW then subtracts whatever regenerative braking is being applied by the ERS-K to keep a consistent braking effort on the rear brakes. If the BBW fails the master cylinder pressure is redirected to the rear brakes, to help stop the car in a balanced way.
As a result of the active BBW control, the brake bias can now be altered electronically via steering wheel buttons. Despite the switch, cars still run dual master cylinders, so the 2021 change will switch to a tandem master cylinder. As the name suggests, this houses pistons for the front and rear brakes in one unit, which infers that the front to rear bias is also fixed. This switch is possible as the rear braking bias is still being taken care of by the BBW unit. The slimline tandem unit takes up less space and is a solution adopted by Formula E for its current season, when it introduced a BBW unit.
With a spec brake pedal and master cylinder the usual variety of set-ups to suit each driver will be restricted. Teams are to propose their preferred sets up to the winning supplier and then a workable solution will be selected, with the FIA arbitrating where necessary. There will be losers in this regard as some drivers drive most confidently with specific brake set up, but this may be tune-able via the BBW.
As mentioned above, the current BBW unit manufacturers are unknown. The units are part of the hydraulic control system, so may use servo valves from Moog and braking components from the team’s brake supplier, assembled into a team designed manifold. Having a spec part here again may affect driver feel, as one of the issues in 2014 was the drivers getting used to the pedal feel from a dead end master cylinder circuit. Subsequent development by the teams and brake suppliers artificially recreated the feel with hydraulic accumulators along with carefully sized pistons and pipework.
Go ad-free for just £1 per month
Allied to the brake system tender is the corresponding change in brake material supply, which consists of the brake disc and the brake pads, both being made from the same material.
Historically there are three suppliers of carbon brake material to F1: Brembo, Carbone Industrie and Hitco. The special brake material is expensive and time-consuming to manufacturer, hence the costs. Then the machining of the bulk material into the finished discs, with their 1,500 cooling holes, and the pads adds further expense. Currently the discs are 278mm in diameter and restricted in thickness to 32mm. While there can only be two brake pads per wheel, which can also be drilled for cooling between the main body of the pad and the area where the caliper piston presses on the pad.
In the tender we learn that with the new larger wheel sizes will accommodate larger brakes so the disc will grow to 320mm or 330mm in diameter. The extreme amount of cooling holes in the current discs will be reduced, as they have grown from 100 holes in 2005 to some 1,500 today, so to cut costs the supplier can elect how many they feel is necessary within budget.
This could create a problem at circuits like Singapore which place a high demand on the brakes, so the supplier will have to offer two brake disc specifications; the cheaper, normal-duty disc with fewer holes, and for at least four circuits on the calendar a heavy-duty disc which is more expensive but provides greater cooling.
The pads must also a multi-directional design, so that just one part can be used on any of the front brake calipers. Additionally, the pad cannot have a drilled rear face.
For the rear brakes the tender is less prescriptive, as they are less stressed than the front brakes due to the braking effect of ERS. Already many teams run thinner rear brake discs and even four-piston rear calipers, as the ERS braking effect is so strong. The supplier will have to propose what diameter and thickness disc is suitable, with the benefit that the FIA are not asking for the braking set-up at the rear to be able to run with an ERS failure.
Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter and
We already know that the wheels will be going to a larger diameter rim size, from the current 13 inches to 18, to make the cars look more like most other current road and race cars. F1’s distinctive ‘balloon’ tyres will disappear, but this is an overdue change.
Along with the spec Pirelli tyres, the wheels themselves will also be a spec part from 2021. The tender is asking for a supply of spec front and rear wheels for the entire grid. Current wheels are fixed in size, but there is an impact with this change, as different spoke design, heat transfer treatments and total weight do vary by team.
Current rules call for AZ70 or AZ80 Magnesium for the wheels, where as the spec wheel material choice is free. This might open up an opportunity for a cheaper wheel material and construction technique. It’s unlikely carbon fibre would be chosen as the spec material, as the cost of manufacture is high and the added cost of post-race inspection for damage would be far higher, especially considering the shorter tyre walls that could lead to rim damage over kerbs.
Any spoke design chosen for the wheel is likely to be inconsequential, as the wheels will be closed off with carbon fibre fairings as part of the aero changes for 2021. This spec fairing might be supplied by the successful wheel supplier, but not necessarily. Regardless the wheel design must accommodate the fairing being fixed to the wheel. So, the 2021 wheel fairings will spin with the wheel, not remain static as when these parts were previously seen in 2008-09.
The wheel supply must also incorporate the inflation valve and provision for one wheel nut. This nut will not be captive, as has been the trend in recent seasons. At pit stops this means the wheel nut will be held in the wheel gun socket and refitted to the new wheel. Both the wheel nut and wheel gun will be part of other spec part tenders.
Finally, the wheel must also provide for a new tyre temperature and pressure sensor (TTPS). This sensor will be detailed in a separate tender, and will be mandatory, even though already teams run homologated TTPS.
- Teams’ updates for Mexican Grand Prix focus on cooling improvements
- Final updates for Mercedes while just two others bring changes for Austin
- Half of F1 teams bring updates for Japanese Grand Prix
- McLaren bring most extensive car update to Singapore Grand Prix
- Seven teams bring drag-reducing upgrades for high-speed Monza